
An appeal is not a second chance at a trial. Rather, it is a review of what happened in the first trial by the appellate court to see if there were any legal mistakes made during that time and whether those mistakes should cause the decision from the first trial to be changed. If you win your appeal, then you will either have a new trial, be resentenced, or in some cases have your conviction overturned.
At LV Criminal Defense, Las Vegas criminal defense attorney Nicholas Wooldridge helps clients examine their legal options following criminal proceedings. If you believe mistakes affected your conviction or sentence, contact LV Criminal Defense to discuss whether an appeal or another form of relief may be appropriate.
Time is critical. Most criminal appeals from Nevada district courts must be initiated within 30 days after entry of the judgment or appealable order. Some appeals have much shorter deadlines. If you have recently been sentenced, do not postpone getting legal advice while you decide whether to challenge the result.
On This Page
Yes. A person convicted of a crime in Nevada may be able to appeal the conviction, the sentence imposed, or certain other appealable decisions made by the trial court. The right to appeal is governed primarily by Nevada Revised Statutes Chapter 177 and the Nevada Rules of Appellate Procedure.
An appeal of a criminal conviction is an attempt by a higher court to review the proceedings of the trial. Typically, this review is conducted using the record from the trial; this includes motions, testimony, evidence, jury instructions, objections and the judge’s decisions.
For instance, if a defendant was convicted of a felony after the jury heard evidence that the defense believed should have been excluded, then an appeal could be filed challenging the judge’s decision to allow that evidence. The appellate court will determine if there was a legal basis for the judge’s decision and if any errors occurred that may have violated the defendant’s rights.
That differs from simply arguing that a witness was lying or that the jury should have believed the defendant instead. Appellate judges do not ordinarily hear witnesses again or independently decide which version of events is more believable.
The essential question is not whether the conviction seems unfair, but whether the record reveals a legal error that can justify appellate relief.
People convicted after jury trials are not the only defendants who may have appellate options. Certain issues can also be raised following a bench trial, a guilty plea, or sentencing. The available grounds and procedures depend on how the case was resolved.
Nevada criminal appeal deadlines are strict. Missing the applicable filing period can result in losing the right to direct appellate review, even when the underlying case presents significant legal issues.
The deadline depends on which court entered the judgment.
| Court where the case originated | General deadline for defendant’s notice of appeal | Court reviewing the appeal |
|---|---|---|
| Nevada state district court | 30 days | Nevada Supreme Court or Court of Appeals |
| Nevada justice or municipal court | 10 days | Appropriate Nevada district court |
| U.S. District Court for the District of Nevada | 14 days | U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit |
These are general rules, not a substitute for calculating the deadline in an individual case. Certain orders, qualifying motions, statutory exceptions, and procedural circumstances can affect the filing period.
For an ordinary Nevada district court criminal appeal, the 30-day period generally begins when the written judgment or appealable order is entered—not merely when the jury announces its verdict or the judge orally imposes sentence.
Nevada Rule of Appellate Procedure 4(b) also explains how certain timely post-trial motions can affect the deadline. However, not every motion extends the time to appeal. A motion to modify or correct a sentence, for example, does not necessarily suspend the deadline for appealing the conviction.
Appeals from Justice Courts and Municipal Courts have different procedures. Under Nevada Rule of Criminal Practice 19, a defendant is normally required to file an appeal within ten days after the entry of the final judgment; or, if there was a written ruling on a motion for a new trial, then thirty days after that ruling, unless otherwise provided by statute.
If you plan to appeal, obtain the written judgment and verify the date it was entered. If you continue to be represented by your trial counsel, notify him/her as soon as possible that you intend to pursue an appeal. Do not assume that discussing a possible appeal, ordering transcripts, or filing another motion will preserve the deadline.
If the deadline may already have passed, there may still be limited options, discussed below.
An appeal must identify a legally recognized error. A defendant does not have to establish that every aspect of the trial was defective, but the argument must provide a legal basis for appellate intervention.
The strongest appeal is not necessarily the one that identifies the greatest number of mistakes. It is the one that focuses on significant, reviewable errors and explains why the law requires relief.
Evidence can make or break a criminal trial. Judges must determine whether evidence is admissible under Nevada law and applicable constitutional protections.
An appeal may challenge a ruling that allowed prejudicial evidence to be presented to the jury or improperly prevented the defense from introducing important evidence. Depending on the circumstances, disputed evidence might include statements obtained in violation of constitutional protections, identification testimony, expert opinions, or evidence whose prejudicial effect substantially outweighed its permissible value.
Adverse evidentiary rulings do not necessarily constitute reversible errors. When evaluating a potential reversible error, an appellate attorney must consider the objection made at trial; the applicable law; and the effect that the disputed evidence had on the trial.
Jurors rely on the trial judge to explain the law they must apply. If those instructions incorrectly describe an element of the crime, the burden of proof, or an available defense, the resulting verdict may be subject to challenge.
For example, an instruction that incorrectly reduces what the prosecution must prove could create a serious appellate issue.
Legal errors can also arise when a judge applies the wrong statute, misunderstands the requirements of an offense, or incorrectly rules on a motion that affects the defense.
Prosecutors are required by law to do more than just obtain convictions. In addition to complying with constitutional disclosure requirements, they must follow court-room conduct rules. There may be many possible reasons for an appeal, including: improper prosecutorial arguments; prejudicial statements made to the jury; and/or failure to provide material evidence that would benefit the defense.
The significance of misconduct depends on the circumstances, including what occurred at trial, whether the defense objected, and whether the conduct affected the defendant’s substantial rights.
If important evidence was discovered only after the trial, the appropriate remedy may instead involve a motion for a new trial or a post-conviction proceeding.
Both the U.S. Constitution and the Nevada Constitution protect criminal defendants. An appeal can bring up constitutional violations that affected the fairness or legality of the trial.
Examples include unlawful limitations on confronting witnesses; discrimination during jury selection; denial of the right to counsel; and other significant procedural violations.
However, the presence of a constitutional issue does not ensure a reversal. Appellate courts use different standards based on the right involved; the type of error; and how the issue was addressed at the trial level.
A defendant may challenge a conviction when the evidence presented at trial was legally insufficient to establish guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
This is a demanding standard. The appellate court generally considers the evidence in the light most favorable to the prosecution and asks whether a rational fact-finder could have found the essential elements of the offense beyond a reasonable doubt.
The argument must go beyond pointing to contradictory testimony or suggesting that another interpretation of the evidence was possible.
An appeal may also challenge the sentence itself.
Possible problems with sentencing are: an unauthorized enhancement; an incorrect calculation of the statutory penalty; using the wrong sentencing law; or imposing a sentence through a legally defective process.
A sentence is not automatically subject to being reversed simply because the defendant thinks it was too long. There must be some type of legitimate legal reason for either changing or vacating the sentence.
No. This is one of the most important limitations of criminal appeals.
Under NRS 177.255, Nevada appellate courts do not reverse judgments for technical errors that do not affect the substantial rights of the parties.
The standard of review also matters. Some legal questions are examined without deference to the trial court, while other decisions are reviewed for abuse of discretion. Errors that were not properly raised before the trial judge may face more restrictive review.
Therefore, an appeal will require much more than simply identifying errors in the trial transcript; the attorney must also determine if those errors can be reviewed, what standard of review applies, and if they may serve as a basis for relief.
An appeal is a process that includes multiple steps; however, each step has its own set of procedures. While every case is different, many direct criminal appeals from Nevada District Courts go through a similar process.
The first thing you need to do is file a notice of appeal with the correct trial court clerk before the deadline has passed. Generally, for Nevada district court criminal cases, the notice will be filed with the district court clerk; however, the appeal itself will go through the state’s appellate system.
The notice formally begins appellate review. It does not, by itself, set out every argument the defendant intends to raise.
The appellate record may include transcripts, motions, orders, exhibits, jury instructions, and other documents from the trial court.
The appellate attorney examines the record to find possible significant errors. A ruling that appeared to be minor at the time of the trial can be crucial to an appeal; however, a seemingly major issue may not be legally sufficient to support an appeal.
One of the most important aspects of this examination is to determine what issues were preserved through objections or other proper action taken during the original proceeding.
The opening brief explains the relevant facts and procedural history, identifies the issues presented, cites controlling legal authority, and argues why the appellate court should grant relief.
The prosecution generally files an answering brief defending the judgment. The defendant may then be permitted to file a reply addressing the prosecution’s arguments.
The appellate attorney examines the record to find possible significant errors. A ruling that appeared to be minor at the time of the trial can be crucial to an appeal; however, a seemingly major issue may not be legally sufficient to support an appeal. One of the most important aspects of this examination is to determine what issues were preserved through objections or other proper action taken during the original proceeding.
The appellate court judges will have an opportunity to ask the attorneys questions regarding the legal issues, applicable precedent and potential effects of the requested relief.
Nevada also uses fast-track procedures for certain criminal appeals, including qualifying guilty-plea and probation-revocation appeals under Rule 3C. Not every criminal appeal qualifies for those procedures.
Once the appellate court has reviewed your appeal, they will make a decision. The appellate court can either uphold (affirm) the lower court’s decision; overturn (reverse) the lower court’s decision; change (modify) the lower court’s decision; or send the case back to the trial court for additional action.
The nature of any relief depends on the legal error found. A successful appeal does not always mean that criminal charges disappear or that the defendant is released immediately.
Nevada has several appellate routes, and the correct route depends on the original court.
Appeals from Nevada district courts. Criminal appeals from state district courts, including the Eighth Judicial District Court in Clark County, enter the Nevada Supreme Court appellate system. Under Rule 17 of the Nevada Rules of Appellate Procedure, the Supreme Court may retain the appeal or assign it to the Nevada Court of Appeals.
Certain categories of cases are presumptively assigned to the Court of Appeals, while others remain with the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court also retains responsibility for categories such as death penalty cases.
Appeals from Justice and Municipal Courts: Criminal appeals from these lower-level courts typically go to the applicable State District Court. The deadlines and procedures used in these types of appeals differ from those used in other types of appeals.
Federal Criminal Appeals: A conviction that occurs at the federal level in the U.S. District Court for the District of Nevada is generally appealed to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. Federal cases are governed by federal appellate rules, not Nevada’s state appellate rules.
These distinctions are important because filing in the wrong place or applying the wrong deadline can jeopardize an appeal. A defendant challenging a federal conviction should have the case evaluated under the rules applicable to federal criminal proceedings.
A guilty plea limits the issues a defendant can raise on direct appeal, but it does not necessarily eliminate every appellate remedy.
Under NRS 177.015(4), a defendant who voluntarily entered a guilty, guilty-but-mentally-ill, or no-contest plea with a full understanding of its consequences generally cannot appeal the resulting judgment unless there are reasonable constitutional, jurisdictional, or other grounds challenging the legality of the proceedings, subject to the statute’s exceptions.
This means that a defendant cannot ordinarily plead guilty and then use an appeal simply to argue that the prosecution would have struggled to prove the case at trial.
However, some challenges may remain available. For example, an appeal might concern an illegal sentence, a jurisdictional defect, or another legal issue that survives the plea. The terms of any plea agreement, including an appeal waiver, must also be reviewed.
Claims that the defendant did not comprehend the plea; was given poor legal advice; or was coerced into entering a guilty plea, can be issues of fact which require a separate post-conviction proceeding as opposed to an ordinary direct appeal.
Do not assume that once you have signed a plea agreement there are no legal remedies available to you. The correct analysis will depend upon the agreement itself; the sentencing record; the alleged error; and the available procedural remedy.
Yes. A criminal appeal does not always have to challenge the finding of guilt. In some cases, a defendant may accept the conviction but challenge the legality of the sentence imposed.
For example, a sentencing appeal could assert that the judge’s sentence was beyond the authorized limits of the law; that the judge incorrectly applied an enhancement; or that the judge based his/her sentencing on an impermissible legal consideration.
In addition to these types of appeals, a sentencing decision can be appealed if the trial court did not follow a required procedure or abused its discretion under the appropriate legal standard.
An appeal is not, however, a general opportunity to ask a different judge for leniency. If the sentence is legally authorized and was imposed through proper procedures, the mere fact that it is severe may not be enough.
Sometimes the appropriate remedy is a motion in the sentencing court rather than a direct appeal. The rules and deadlines for those remedies differ, and filing a sentence-correction motion does not necessarily preserve the direct appeal deadline.
Determining the correct procedure is particularly important when the defendant pleaded guilty and the dispute concerns only sentencing.
The outcome of a criminal appeal depends on both the legal issue and the relief the appellate court considers appropriate.
When an appellate court affirms a conviction and/or sentence, the original conviction and/or sentence will remain in effect. However, depending upon the facts of each case, there may be other options for appellate review and/or post-conviction relief; however, these options are subject to specific procedural requirements and time limits.
When an appellate court reverses a conviction, it can either direct a new trial be held or grant some other form of relief. A reversal does not require that the prosecutor dismiss the charges.
If the sentence is set aside, the case may return to the trial court for resentencing or correction of the identified error.
If the case is remanded, the trial court must carry out the proceedings directed by the appellate decision. The scope of those proceedings depends on the court’s instructions.
Nevada’s appellate courts also have authority under NRS 177.265 to affirm, reverse, or modify judgments and, when appropriate, order a new trial.
There is no single timetable for completing a Nevada criminal appeal. Some cases are resolved in several months, while complex appeals can take considerably longer.
The amount of time it takes to complete an appeal will depend on how long it takes to prepare the transcript; what types of issues were raised; the briefing schedule; the court’s workload; and if oral arguments or other proceedings are required.
While fast-track procedures can help speed up certain parts of the process, the use of this term does not ensure a specific decision date or a positive outcome.
The time needed to prepare an appeal is different from the deadline to begin one. Even when appellate review will take months, the initial notice of appeal may still need to be filed within days.
Missing a direct appeal deadline is serious, but the facts surrounding the missed deadline should be examined before assuming that every option has been lost.
Nevada Rule of Appellate Procedure 4(c) provides a limited mechanism for a delayed direct appeal when a defendant was unlawfully deprived of the right to appeal and obtains the necessary relief through a timely and properly filed post-conviction habeas proceeding.
For example, a defendant who clearly requested an appeal but was unlawfully deprived of that right may have grounds to seek relief. The defendant must establish the required claim, and the district court must make the findings necessary to authorize the delayed appeal.
Rule 4(c) is not a general extension available simply because someone changed their mind or overlooked a deadline.
Other legal remedies may be available depending on the case. Nevada’s post-conviction procedures allow certain challenges to convictions and sentences through petitions for writs of habeas corpus.
Under NRS 34.726, a petition challenging a Nevada conviction or sentence generally must be filed within one year after entry of the judgment, or, when there has been a direct appeal, within one year after issuance of the appellate remittitur, unless a legally sufficient exception applies.
These proceedings are not interchangeable with direct appeals. They have different purposes, evidentiary requirements, and procedural restrictions.
If your appeal deadline has passed, review our guide to post-conviction relief in Nevada. An attorney can evaluate whether a delayed appeal, habeas petition, or other remedy is legally available.
A criminal appeal is very different than how you defend your case at trial. Trial attorneys focus on presenting evidence, witnesses, making objections, and convincing the fact finder. Appellate representation is focused on the record that already exists, applying appropriate legal standards, preparing written arguments, and identifying available remedies under the law.
A criminal appeals lawyer must separate potentially reversible mistakes from issues that are unlikely to succeed on review.
At LV Criminal Defense, attorney Nicholas Wooldridge has practiced law since 2004 and founded the Las Vegas firm in 2015. His criminal defense practice includes serious state and federal prosecutions in Nevada.
When deciding if you should file a criminal appeal, there are several very important questions to ask yourself. These include: Can I appeal the judgment? Am I within the time limit to file? What errors were preserved? Are the facts of my case sufficient to support an appellate challenge?
A review will typically include reviewing court decisions; identifying available records; reviewing sentencing issues; and determining if the case requires a direct appeal or another type of post-conviction relief. The goal is not to guarantee that a conviction can be overturned.
Rather, it is to determine what remedies are allowed under the law and assess whether there is both a factual and legal basis to seek those remedies.
If you are considering an appeal, it is helpful to have your case number, written judgment, plea agreement if applicable, sentencing information, and contact details for your previous attorney. You do not need to have every transcript or court filing before seeking an initial discussion.
LV Criminal Defense serves clients in Las Vegas, Henderson, Summerlin, and throughout Nevada. Contact our office to discuss your conviction, sentence, and possible next steps.
No. An appeal involves a higher court reviewing legal issues arising from the original proceedings. A new trial involves presenting the case again in a trial court. An appellate court may order a new trial if it determines that the law requires that remedy, but not every successful appeal produces one.
You might be able to appeal based upon established legal principles such as lack of evidence or an error in the conduct of your trial; however, in most cases an appeal is not an opportunity to provide a whole new set of facts. If you find out about new evidence after your conviction you will likely need to use a different procedure (such as a motion for a new trial) rather than attempting to introduce this evidence at the time of your appeal.
In general, direct appellate review is limited to the record created in the trial court. New testimony, forensic evidence, etc., which was not available at the time of your conviction can be used to support a motion for a new trial or other post-conviction relief depending on the specifics of each case and the timing requirements.
Filing an appeal does not automatically suspend imprisonment. Under NRS 177.105, a sentence of imprisonment is stayed when an appeal is taken and the defendant is admitted to bail. Whether release pending appeal is available depends on the governing law and the court’s decision.
Certain orders revoking or modifying probation may be appealed. Nevada Rule of Appellate Procedure 3C provides fast-track procedures for qualifying probation appeals when the defendant was represented by counsel in district court. The appellate issues differ from those involved in challenging the original conviction. See our separate guide to probation violations in Nevada.
If you requested an appeal or were otherwise unlawfully deprived of the right to pursue one, there may be a basis for seeking relief through Nevada’s post-conviction procedures. The outcome depends on the facts, the timing, and whether the requirements for a delayed appeal can be established. Prompt legal review is important.
Ineffective assistance of counsel may be a valid reason for relief; however, Nevada courts typically do not decide ineffective assistance of counsel claims on direct appeal if there needs to be additional fact-finding. Generally, ineffective assistance of counsel claims are resolved through post-conviction habeas proceedings, with few exceptions. What remedy is appropriate will depend upon what counsel allegedly did wrong and how that conduct impacted the case.
Perhaps. Depending on what appellate court heard the appeal, there may be limited additional review available. Post-conviction habeas corpus relief may also be an option for claims that were appropriately raised through the post-conviction habeas corpus process. Both remedies have strict filing requirements and issues that have been addressed on appeal cannot necessarily be relitigated.
A conviction or sentence may feel like the end of your case. But where the law provides grounds for an appeal, the decisions made immediately afterward can be critical.
An appellate court will not reverse a conviction simply because the result was disappointing. It must have a legal basis to intervene. That makes an early review of the judgment, trial record, potential errors, and filing deadlines especially important.
If you or a family member has been convicted of a crime in Nevada, contact LV Criminal Defense to discuss the available options for appealing a criminal conviction or sentence. Attorney Nicholas Wooldridge and the firm can help you evaluate the legal questions that need to be addressed before deciding how to proceed.
Call 702-623-6362 or request a consultation with LV Criminal Defense.
LV Criminal Defense
300 S. 4th Street, Suite 950
Las Vegas, NV 89101
Every criminal appeal depends on the facts, procedural history, and applicable law. No particular result can be guaranteed.