Two defendants can ask to take back the same kind of plea and face different rules because one has already been sentenced. NRS 176.165, part of Nevada’s Judgment and Execution chapter, applies to pleas of guilty, guilty but mentally ill, and nolo contendere (no contest). The statute sets the ordinary cutoff for a withdrawal motion at the point when the court imposes sentence or suspends its imposition.
In Stevenson v. State, the Nevada Supreme Court held that a district court must look at all the circumstances to decide whether allowing withdrawal before sentencing would be fair and just. Whether the defendant understood the plea and entered it voluntarily matters, and the court can consider circumstances beyond the plea’s validity.
In Stevenson, the defendant argued that he was forced into making a plea by being “pressured” and “confused” as to whether or not he could see the surveillance video prior to entering his plea. The Court looked at the entire context of the plea, including how long after the plea the defendant waited to move to withdraw. This delay lessened the credibility of the defendant’s explanation of a short-term confusion. Therefore, the Court found no error in denying the motion to withdraw.
According to NRS 176.165, the court may set aside the judgment of conviction and permit withdrawal in order to correct manifest injustice. In Harris v. State, the Nevada Supreme Court discussed the application of these words after sentencing. The standard for reviewing a post-conviction challenge to the validity of a guilty plea is outlined. After sentencing, a defendant challenging the validity of a guilty plea generally must file a post-conviction petition for a writ of habeas corpus under NRS Chapter 34, subject to its custody and filing requirements.
For convictions based on a plea of guilty or guilty but mentally ill, NRS 34.810 generally limits these petitions to claims that the plea was involuntary or unknowing, or that the defendant entered it without effective assistance of counsel.
Under NRS 34.726, a post-conviction relief petition challenging a conviction must be filed within one year of the date of entry of the judgment of conviction. If the defendant files a timely direct appeal, the one year time period for filing a post-conviction relief petition runs from the date that the appellate court issues its remittitur in the direct appeal.
In order to show good cause for filing a petition late, the petitioner must establish that the delay was through no fault of the petitioner and that the petitioner would be unduly prejudiced by a dismissal as untimely.
See Nevada’s post-conviction relief procedures for more information on the eligibility and deadline for filing a petition for post-conviction relief.
The case will be returned to active prosecution. The state may prosecute the original charges and/or negotiate a new agreement. A withdrawn guilty or guilty-but-mentally-ill plea is inadmissible in any criminal proceeding against the person who entered the plea. A no-contest plea is inadmissible in any civil or criminal proceeding against the person who entered the plea.
See Nevada criminal pleas guide for additional information about the various plea options available as the case moves forward.